This homemade pumpkin donuts recipe has the rich cakey texture of an old fashioned donut with the perfect crispy outside. I tried a few different recipes before I decided that this is the BEST buttermilk doughnut recipe on the planet!!
I have to confess that baking is not my favorite area of cooking.
However, when the holidays roll around, I find that I enjoy baking the recipes that make me feel nostalgic.
All the baking takes me back to the days before mortgages and responsible food choices.
So why not bake up a metric ton of old fashioned glazed donuts and, of course, homemade donut holes. Then crack open a bottle of prosecco and make it a party!
Foodology Geek Recipe Notes
What do you need to make homemade donuts?
- Dry Ingredients: Whole wheat pastry flour, baking powder, and sugar.
- Wet Ingredients: Vanilla, canned pumpkin puree, melted butter, and buttermilk.
- Spices: Pumpkin pie spice OR cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, and cloves.
If you haven't already, grab a copy of my Sweet Spices Download. It has my grandma's pumpkin pie spice mix recipe plus a few others that you are definitely going to want to try.
Special Equipment For Making Donuts
- Donut cutter: A handy dandy donut cutter makes quick work of cutting out donuts and donut holes in one shot.
- A heavy cast iron pot: Cast iron holds it's temperature very well and is perfect for keeping oil at just the right temperature.
- Candy thermometer: A thermometer will help you to regulate the temperature so that you have perfectly cooked donuts every time.
Step By Step Instructions
Making Old Fashioned Buttermilk Donuts might be a lengthy process, but it's totally worth it. These donuts have the perfect texture and and flavor that you'd expect from a classic old fashioned donut.
- Mix up the batter: Add the wet ingredients to your mixer and mix until fluffy. Add in the flour and mix until the flour is just mixed in. The dough will be sticky.
- Roll out the donut dough: Flour your work surface and roll out the donut dough to about one-inch thickness.
- Cut the donuts: Cut out the donuts. Set aside on parchment paper. Re-roll the dough and continue to cut out as many donuts as you can. This recipe should make about 24 donuts.
- Make the glaze: While your oil is heating up make the glaze. You will want to glaze the donuts while they are still warm.
- Fry the donuts: Heat the oil to 325℉. Add 4 to 5 donuts to the oil at a time. Don't crowd them too much. Fry on one side until golden brown, then flip over and fry on the other side. (see below for detailed times)
How to make glazed donuts
This old fashioned donut recipe uses a buttermilk glaze. It's made of buttermilk and powdered sugar. I chose to add a little bit of pumpkin spice to the glaze just to give it a little more pumpkin spice flavor.
After frying the donuts you should dunk them into the glaze while they are still warm.
Remove the donuts from the oil and place them onto a paper towel. Then while they are still hot dunk them in the glaze and place them on a wire rack.
FAQS and Substitutions
I didn't have a donut cutter when I made this recipe, so I used a round cookie cutter. It's has a three and a half-inch diameter.
You can also order a set of round pastry cutters HERE.
To cut out the centers, which become homemade donut holes, I used a shot glass. I know! Classy!
When I started on my mission to tackle making homemade donuts, of course, this was my first question.
What I found; Donuts are easy to make at home if you have the right equipment.
You'll also need the best donut recipe and the perfect donut glaze recipe. Because honestly, what is a donut if it's not a glazed donut?
Luckily this recipe for gluten-free pumpkin donuts has already been tested by one of my best friends, who happens to be sensitive to gluten. She and her husband made this recipe using a gluten-free flour blend.
They made a huge batch of pumpkin donut holes and raved about how delicious they were, even gluten-free!
PRO-TIP: Dip the edges of the donut cutting tools into flour before each cut so that the dough comes out easily.
Check out a few other pumpkin recipes that I have here.
- Mini Pumpkin Tarts
- Peanut Butter and Pumpkin Dog Treats
- Pumpkin Cheesecake Bars
- Pumpkin Oats
- No-Bake Pumpkin Bites
- Pumpkin Curry Soup
- Vegan Pumpkin Pie
Then If You Still Want MORE Check out Some other Baking Recipes
- Cinnamon Rolls with Cream Cheese Frosting
- Hawaiian Pineapple Sweet Rolls
- The Ultimate Banana Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting
- The Best Banana Bread Recipe
- Banana Cream Pie
- Cranberry Sour Cream Coffee Cake
Old Fashioned Glazed Pumpkin Donuts
- 3 cups powdered sugar
- ½ cup buttermilk
- ½ tsp vanilla or maple extract
- In a large bowl, combine all of the dry ingredients.
- In a stand mixer combine the butter, pumpkin puree, and the vanilla extract. Beat with the paddle attachment until the mixture is light and fluffy.
- Add the buttermilk, mix until incorporated.
- Add the dry ingredients and mix until everything is well combined.
- The batter will be pretty sticky. (This dough can be made a day ahead and rested overnight in the the fridge)
- Make the buttermilk glaze before frying. (see below)
- Turn out the dough onto a well-floured surface.
- Roll the dough to a half-inch thick. Use a donut cutter to cut donuts.
- Heat the Canola oil to 325°F. Drop donuts in, fry for 10 seconds, and then flip. Fry for about 90 seconds and flip again. Fry for another 90 seconds.
- Remove the donuts from the oil and place them on a paper towel.
- Dip each donut in the buttermilk glaze while still hot. Then place the dounts on a rack to cool .
- Combine all ingredients for glaze in a bowl and whisk together.
- Note: An infinite number of flavorings can be added to this glaze. Maple instead of vanilla. Citrus juice instead of the buttermilk. Be creative.